
It's Beginning To Sound A Lot Like Christmas
Laura Finney
11/19/2026
I am an annoying and unapologetic seasonalist. I admit it. I choose to move through my year in a thoughtful and rather plodding manner. In the land of Laura, we do not put away the Fourth of July decorations and start plotting Halloween when we aren’t even halfway to Labor Day. Each holiday needs to stay in its own lane.
And I have always drawn a hard line when it comes to Christmas Carols. I would march right out of a store in righteous protest if they dared to pipe in “It’s Beginning to Look a Lot Like Christmas” while I’m out shopping for my pumpkin. It is not beginning to look a lot like anything. It is pumpkin spice season and although I hate that stuff with a burning passion, I will support its right to be the star of the October show. Santa can just turn that sleigh around and wait his turn.
November, of course, was reserved for Thanksgiving. And Thanksgiving meant listening to Alice’s Restaurant Massacree. My daughter maintains that this is not what people do on Thanksgiving. I maintain that this is exactly what people who have been properly raised and well loved do. We beat the life out of the potatoes while singing along to Arlo’s ridiculously long, improbably catchy epic.
My husband doesn’t even need us to put the song on. All I have to say is “Alice’s Restaurant” and wherever he is, I’ll hear, “I mean, I’m sitting here on the Group W bench.”
And so, we wait, for the sun to rise on the day after Thanksgiving before we finally give in to the 24/7 Christmas music channel. Previously, this was a hill on which I was willing to die. No Christmas until Thanksgiving has been safely put away. Until this year …
And in order to understand this next part, I need to share with you that several years ago, in my Grinchiest manner, I declared that we would no longer be celebrating Christmas.
For decades, I’d haul the tree off the roof of my car (while heavily under the influence of Benadryl because I am wildly allergic to pine), wrestle it into the stand that was clearly designed by a sadist, and take myself off to the attic to uncover the Christmas decorations.
I’d spend hours untangling the lights I’d spent hours coiling in January for the express purpose of never having to untangle them again.
Under the watchful eye of my husband, I would dress the tree in lights, all while being reminded that his father used to spend hours on this part. Apparently, his father used up all of his family light trimming hours because I don’t recall ever seeing my husband so much as touch a light.
In my mind, tree decorating by firelight with Christmas songs playing in the background is one of the joys of the holiday season. In reality, as a family, we have the attention spans of squirrels on crack. We’d start strong, pulling out our favorite ornaments of Christmas past. By ornament three the joy had abated and by ornament six, sports, TikTok’s and YouTube videos were beckoning us away. Minimalism in a tree is good, I’d tell myself.
I could go on but I think you get the picture.
Every family has the person who makes the holiday happen. In ours, that was me. In the beginning, we all enjoy the magic. Then the magic turns to hives and you find yourself three Benadryl deep, sneaking off to the spare room to wrap gifts, swearing if you hear “Last Christmas” one more time you’re going to kill someone. I’m pretty sure this was not what Jesus had envisioned.
So, I canceled it.
As so often happens in cases such as this, we wound up in South Florida in an all-inclusive where faceless strangers have already dressed the place up and made the meals and even wrapped the fake packages. It was heaven.
Which brings us back to this year. It has been a stunningly beautiful, warm fall in Maryland. The kind of weather that makes you want to write a thank-you note to whoever’s in charge of weather. As I write this, I’m wearing a t-shirt and shorts on a 70° day, and Thanksgiving is apparently a week away. I’ve checked this, twice, because it seems like the weather has not gotten the memo.
Yet, earlier this week, I woke up, looked at my husband and declared, “I want to put on Christmas music…Right now.” I braced for the pushback.
I was already preparing my rebuttal. For 28 years, we had agreed that Christmas music had to wait until after Thanksgiving. We would die on that hill together and if someone played “Jingle Bell Rock” at the funeral, we’d rise from our caskets and walk out.
“Let’s do it,” he said.
Well, now I was alarmed. I’d expected to spend the next ten minutes arguing with him. I hadn’t prepared for the possibility that we’d both lost our minds.
It wasn’t even sweater weather. I could have put on Bing Crosby and gone out to the patio to sunbathe. And yet there we were, two people who had spent nearly three decades taking a principled stand on when a dead man could sing about snow, suddenly in complete agreement that we needed him immediately.
After all these years, I’d have thought one of us would at least have the decency to say, “What the hell is wrong with you?”
So here we are, Christmas music playing in the background, eggnog in the fridge, the pumpkin still sitting by the front door and tomorrow the hammock is coming back out of storage.
Maybe I’ve finally learned that it’s okay to smush the holidays together. Sometimes you need a little Christmas, along with some sunblock.
Or maybe we’ve slipped into a parallel universe.
Either way, tomorrow I’ll be in the hammock. You will probably find my husband twirling a pencil and happily lolling on the Group W bench.
**Because I worry that there might be some of you out there who have never had the pleasure of listening to Alice’s Restaurant, I’m providing a link. Come Thanksgiving, turn the volume down on the parade or dog show and enjoy this strange little journey as you whip those potatoes into shape.