Who Are You Wearing?

Laura Finney

11/12/2026

There was a young boy at the market yesterday, wearing his Halloween costume. I watched his mother trying to maneuver an unwieldy cart, a crying baby riding shotgun, all while Spider-Man darted this way and that. He shot a web at the four-for-a-dollar limes and scurried off to look for danger in the bakery aisle.

I looked down at my Lululemon leggings and walking shoes that desperately need to be replaced and wondered when I’d gotten to be such a utilitarian dresser? When was the last time I’d put on an outfit and become someone else entirely?

He’d dressed for the possibility that he’d have to save civilization. I had dressed for the possibility that I’d have to move a washing machine.

In the moment, my outfit made perfect sense. I’d been out walking with my neighbor, and I had plans to whittle down the mess that our laundry room had become. Not to mention, this is the uniform of my people. Leggings, workout top, sneakers, hair in a ponytail – I’m sure you’ve seen at least half a dozen of us already today.

And I do own other clothes. Somewhere in my closet are outfits that suggest I might be invited for drinks, entrusted with a real estate transaction, or attending something involving a committee (by the way, I will not be attending something involving a committee.) But left to my own devices, I dress as if I might suddenly have to change my own oil.

As I stood in the market, watching this little boy for what some would consider an inappropriate amount of time, I wondered – if I were to show up in a costume, what would it be?

Right off the top of my head, I could rule out a large swath of possibilities. I’ve never been a fru-fru princess type. All of that puffy sleeved, crinoline nonsense would make me crazy. I also find historical anything deeply unsettling so scratch that. I could rule out most of the superheroes. Honestly, I always found Wonder Woman’s outfit utterly unbecoming. Gentlemen, do not come at me for that. It’s just my opinion.

Apparently, even my fantasy wardrobe has a fairly restrictive dress code.

So, I thought I’d tackle it from the inside out. How would I want to feel in my costume. Strong. Confident. Quietly capable of handling whatever came my way. I’d want to walk into the room knowing that I had every right to be there. To encounter a problem and trust that I could handle it, perhaps with a little humor. Preferably in something with pockets.

And then it occurred to me that there are people who would already describe me that way. Was I just the right outfit away from feeling that myself? And what on earth would that look like?

Unfortunately, “a woman who trusts her own judgment” isn’t a searchable category at Party City. I could go with slutty pirate and have any number of options but when it comes to “quiet self-assured fifty-something,” I’m on my own - although J. McLaughlin is trying.

When my godson was little, he informed his mother that he was going to win the Easter egg hunt. His secret weapon? He was wearing his Power Ranger underpants.

My costume needs Power Ranger underpants. Not literally. That would be weird and creepy, but also kind of hilarious. You get the idea. I need clothing that imbues me with the sort of confidence previously only experienced by five year old boys wearing superhero undergarments.

I have a pair of sneakers that sort of fit the bill. I cannot adequately describe them, but they are the sort of shoes that make me look like I could actually kick ass while still being vaguely fashionable. They are the kind of shoes that other fifty-something women stop me to say love your shoes. And we nod to one another, knowing that they are carrying more responsibility than your typical athletic footwear.

But what of the rest of the outfit. I can’t walk around with ass kicking tennis shoes and not complete the ensemble. After all, Wonder Woman wandering the streets in sweatpants and a hoodie carrying only her lasso would look more like a woman off to resolve an issue with Comcast than a hero meting out justice.

I tried to play this What’s Your Costume game with my husband but he’s no fun. It turns out he already wears his costume every day. In fairness, he’s a pretty meticulous dresser so I shouldn’t have been surprised to learn that he already dresses for the way he wants to feel. Then again, only one of us is ever going to get around to cleaning out the garage and that one is not wearing a tweed sport coat.

Of course, there is something quietly capable about the person who cleans out the garage (are you starting to get the feeling that this is a bone of contention in our house?) I’d prefer that my superpowers manifest themselves in less messy ways but apparently, we don’t get to choose everything.

Perhaps I’m being unfair to my current wardrobe. After all, these are the clothes I wear while figuring things out. Handling difficult client conversations, navigating strange new health concerns, assembling furniture with instructions that would leave an MIT engineer weeping in the corner.

I’ve managed all of that without so much as a cape … or clean hair.

Still, I think there’s room for an outfit that reminds me of something I tend to forget. One that makes me stand a little straighter before I’ve even had a chance to talk myself out of whatever I’m about to do.

That little boy wasn’t waiting until he’d apprehended someone in the deli department to feel like Spider-Man. He’d gotten dressed that morning and considered the matter settled.

That’s all I’m asking. I’d like a little of that certainty. To look in the mirror and think, yes, she’s got this. I’ll start with the shoes. Perhaps the rest of the outfit will come with time.

But if you see me in the superhero underwear department … mind your own business.

Connect

Sharing stories and tips for alpha-gal life

Contact

Subscribe

© 2025. All rights reserved.